For decades, aquariums have captivated audiences with their mesmerizing displays of marine life. For many, they bring back memories of Free Willy and its emotional story of a captive orca’s fight for freedom—a film that helped spark a global conversation about the ethics of marine mammal captivity. Yet, while aquariums offer unforgettable experiences and education, they’ve also been at the center of heated controversy.
From accusations of animal cruelty to heartbreaking incidents like the recent viral images of a bleeding killer whale at Marineland, aquariums have faced scrutiny over their treatment of animals and the ethics of keeping marine life in tanks. These criticisms are well-founded, as the history of captive marine animals often includes inadequate living conditions and questionable practices.
However, the tide is beginning to turn. Many aquariums in the United States are shifting away from entertainment-first models to become leaders in conservation, rescue, and public education. They’re making significant efforts to improve animal welfare and address their troubling reputations, though challenges remain. Here are some of the best aquariums in the U.S., exploring how they’re trying to make amends for the past and lead the way toward a more compassionate future for marine life.
1. Georgia Aquarium (Atlanta, Georgia)
The Georgia Aquarium, one of the largest in the world, has faced criticism in the past for keeping large marine mammals like beluga whales and whale sharks in captivity. However, it has made strides in improving its care standards, focusing on animal rescue and rehabilitation programs. For example, the aquarium actively supports research on endangered species and provides a sanctuary for animals unable to return to the wild. While their enormous Ocean Voyager exhibit is breathtaking, critics question whether any tank can truly replicate the vastness of the ocean.
2. Monterey Bay Aquarium (Monterey, California)
Monterey Bay Aquarium has long been considered a leader in ethical practices, avoiding controversial displays of large marine mammals altogether. Instead, it focuses on sustainable seafood initiatives, ocean health advocacy, and the rehabilitation of sea otters and seabirds. While it has largely escaped the harsh scrutiny faced by some of its counterparts, even this respected institution is part of an industry that often grapples with the morality of animal captivity.
3. Shedd Aquarium (Chicago, Illinois)
Shedd Aquarium has faced backlash in the past for keeping dolphins and belugas in tanks that some activists argue are too small for their complex needs. In response, Shedd has shifted its focus toward marine rescue efforts and advancing research in coral restoration. While the facility emphasizes animal welfare and sustainability, critics remain skeptical about the ethics of displaying highly intelligent marine mammals for entertainment purposes.
4. National Aquarium (Baltimore, Maryland)
Flickr
The National Aquarium has taken bold steps to address concerns about animal cruelty, including phasing out marine mammal performances and planning a sanctuary for its captive dolphins. These initiatives are a promising sign of progress, though the transition has been slow. Critics argue that the aquarium’s remaining exhibits, while educational, still fail to provide an ideal environment for some species.
5. Aquarium of the Pacific (Long Beach, California)
Long Beach Nightlife
This aquarium is known for its conservation programs and advocacy for vulnerable species, such as the critically endangered Vaquita Porpoise. However, it has also faced scrutiny for keeping large marine mammals like sea lions and harbor seals in relatively small spaces. While its sustainability initiatives are commendable, the Aquarium of the Pacific, like others, continues to wrestle with the inherent limitations of captivity.
6. Clearwater Marine Aquarium (Clearwater, Florida)
Flickr
Clearwater Marine Aquarium specializes in rescuing and rehabilitating injured marine animals, often releasing them back into the wild. While it avoids the controversies tied to traditional aquariums, some critics argue that the facility’s focus on high-profile animals, like Winter the dolphin, leans too heavily on emotional appeal rather than addressing systemic issues in marine captivity.
7. Mystic Aquarium (Mystic, Connecticut)
Pexels
Mystic Aquarium has been at the center of controversy for importing five beluga whales from Canada, sparking debates about whether these transfers prioritize research or exploitation. While Mystic conducts valuable Arctic research and rescues stranded seals, the decision to keep belugas in captivity has drawn criticism from animal rights groups who argue that these social animals deserve more space than any tank can provide.
8. Tennessee Aquarium (Chattanooga, Tennessee)
Flickr
The Tennessee Aquarium has largely avoided controversies surrounding marine mammals by focusing on freshwater and saltwater fish and invertebrates. While it supports conservation efforts like reintroducing endangered species, critics argue that any form of captivity can disrupt natural behaviors, even for less charismatic species.
9. Seattle Aquarium (Seattle, Washington)
YouTube
Seattle Aquarium has been vocal in its advocacy for Southern Resident Killer Whales, a critically endangered population in Puget Sound. However, some critics point out the irony of an institution advocating for wild orca conservation while keeping other marine animals in captivity. The aquarium’s research and outreach efforts are important, but they don’t fully address concerns about captive animal welfare.
10. Audubon Aquarium of the Americas (New Orleans, Louisiana)
Flickr
This aquarium is praised for its efforts to rescue and rehabilitate animals affected by hurricanes and oil spills. However, its exhibits, which include large sea creatures like sharks, have drawn criticism for prioritizing visitor engagement over optimal living conditions. The aquarium continues to walk a fine line between education and exploitation.
11. Oregon Coast Aquarium (Newport, Oregon)
Flickr
This facility gained fame as the former home of Keiko, the orca who starred in Free Willy. Despite its role in Keiko’s rehabilitation and eventual release, the aquarium has faced ongoing criticism for keeping marine mammals in captivity. It now focuses on smaller-scale conservation efforts, but the shadow of its past remains.
12. Texas State Aquarium (Corpus Christi, Texas)
Flickr
The Texas State Aquarium emphasizes rescue and rehabilitation, particularly for sea turtles and birds. While its conservation programs are commendable, some critics argue that its exhibits don’t always prioritize animal welfare. Its Wildlife Rescue Center is a step in the right direction, but the broader concerns about captivity persist.
Conclusion: A Complicated Current
Aquariums have come a long way in addressing concerns about animal cruelty and captivity, but their progress is often overshadowed by high-profile controversies, such as the bleeding killer whale at Marineland or the ongoing debate over keeping dolphins and orcas in captivity. While many U.S. aquariums are making significant strides in conservation, rescue, and education, the inherent limitations of captivity remain.
The shift toward prioritizing animal welfare and ethical practices is encouraging, but it’s clear that this journey is far from complete. For visitors, supporting aquariums that are actively working to improve care standards and contribute to conservation efforts can make a difference. Still, the question lingers: can these facilities truly replicate the ocean’s freedom for their inhabitants, or will aquariums always remain a compromise between human fascination and animal well-being?
