1. Last Known Sighting
Jean Spangler was last definitively seen on Friday, October 7, 1949, around 6:00 p.m., not far from her home in the Park La Brea area. A sales clerk at the Original Farmers Market, a few blocks from her apartment, recalled seeing the aspiring actress browsing and noted that she seemed to be waiting for someone. This fleeting moment remains the final confirmed sighting of Spangler. Before leaving home around 5:00 p.m., Spangler had told her sister-in-law, Sophie, that she was meeting her ex-husband, Dexter Benner, to discuss a late child support payment, and then going to work on a night film shoot. However, both of those stated plans were later refuted, deepening the mystery of her true intent that evening.
2. The Cryptic Note to “Kirk”
Two days after her disappearance, Spangler’s tattered purse was discovered in a remote area of Griffith Park, approximately five miles from her home. Inside, among her belongings, was a mysterious, unfinished note, written in her handwriting. It was addressed to a person named “Kirk,” and read: “Kirk, Can’t wait any longer. Going to see Dr. Scott. It will work best this way while mother is away.” The note was unsigned and ended abruptly, as if she had been interrupted while writing it. Police ruled out robbery as a motive since Spangler’s sister-in-law confirmed Jean had no money when she left home that night, though the absence of cash in the purse was noted.
3. Purse Found in Griffith Park
The location where Spangler’s purse was recovered, the Fern Dell area of Griffith Park, added a grim layer to the investigation. At the time, this area was known for being a spot where illicit or criminal activities occasionally occurred, suggesting a possible link to foul play. Furthermore, the purse itself was damaged; both straps on one side were torn loose, which suggested it might have been forcefully ripped from her arm during a struggle. Sixty police officers and over a hundred volunteers launched a massive search of the 4,107-acre park, but no other trace of Spangler or additional evidence was ever found.
4. Connection to Kirk Douglas
Public speculation immediately linked the “Kirk” mentioned in the note to famous Hollywood actor Kirk Douglas, with whom Jean Spangler had recently worked as an extra on the film Young Man with a Horn. The case attracted significant media attention, and Douglas himself was compelled to issue a statement to the Los Angeles police via telegram. He denied ever dating Spangler or knowing her outside of brief, professional interactions on the film set. While he admitted to “talking and kidding” with her, he adamantly denied any involvement or knowledge of her disappearance.
5. Alleged Pregnancy and “Dr. Scott”
The mention of “Dr. Scott” in the cryptic note led investigators down the path of a possible botched, illegal abortion. Friends of Spangler told police that she was approximately three months pregnant when she vanished and that she had discussed getting an abortion, which was a dangerous and illegal procedure in 1949. The LAPD questioned every doctor in the Los Angeles area with the last name Scott, but none had a patient named Spangler or Benner (her married name). This theory suggested that “Dr. Scott” may have been an alias for a back-alley practitioner.
6. The Missing Night Shoot Alibi
Jean Spangler told her sister-in-law she was leaving home to work on a film set, claiming she had a night shoot. This provided an alibi for her overnight absence and was part of her explanation for not returning home until the next day. However, a check with all the major film studios quickly determined that no film was in production that night, and certainly none required Spangler’s presence as a dancer or extra. Her false statement immediately put a cloud of suspicion over her true intentions and the nature of her meeting that night.
7. Ex-Husband’s Denial
Spangler’s initial statement to her sister-in-law was that she was meeting her ex-husband, Dexter Benner, to discuss overdue child support for their five-year-old daughter, Christine. However, when police questioned Benner, he and his new wife both maintained that he had not seen Jean Spangler for several weeks. Benner’s statement was a major point of conflict in the early investigation, as it directly contradicted the last verifiable information Spangler had given about her whereabouts. Police could not definitively disprove Benner’s alibi, and no substantial evidence ever linked him to her disappearance.
8. The ‘Scotty’ Connection
Despite the search for a “Dr. Scott,” police also investigated another lead: a man Spangler had been involved with years prior whom she had referred to as “Scotty.” Spangler’s lawyer confirmed that she had once dated an abusive former lover by that name, but claimed she had not seen him since 1945. This “Scotty” was believed to be a non-practicing doctor or medical student. The resurfacing of the name in the note, even if under the title “Dr. Scott”, suggested Spangler may have been in contact with him again, potentially related to her alleged pregnancy.
9. Potential Ties to the Mob
Investigators explored the possibility that Spangler had fled or been abducted by organized crime figures. During the late 1940s, Hollywood’s underbelly was dominated by figures like mob boss Mickey Cohen. Spangler had briefly dated Davy Ogul, a known associate of Cohen, who was also a key figure in a pending federal case involving a $191,000 fraud charge. Both Ogul and his associate, Frank Niccoli, vanished around the same time as Spangler, fueling theories that she had either gone into hiding with them to avoid testifying or that she had been silenced by the mob.
10. Custody Battle History
Jean Spangler had a complicated and tumultuous history with her ex-husband, Dexter Benner, including an ongoing legal battle over the custody of their daughter, Christine. Following their divorce, Benner initially had primary custody of Christine, claiming Spangler was an unfit mother who “preferred parties to priorities.” However, Spangler was later awarded full custody in 1948. This history of bitter conflict gave Benner a potential, though unproven, motive related to the disappearance, even though he was seemingly cleared by his alibi.
11. The Florentine Gardens Link
Before her disappearance, Spangler was working as a dancer at the famed Florentine Gardens nightclub in Hollywood. This detail became significant to investigators because the establishment was also linked to another high-profile, unsolved Hollywood murder: that of Elizabeth Short, the “Black Dahlia,” whose mutilated body was found in 1947. While there was no concrete evidence connecting the two cases, the similar backgrounds of the victims, both aspiring young women with ties to Hollywood’s dance and nightlife scene, led to unsettling comparisons.
12. Spangler’s Last Phone Call Home – Sophie
Approximately two and a half hours after leaving home, Jean Spangler called her sister-in-law, Sophie, around 7:30 p.m. Spangler was calling to check on her young daughter, Christine, who was sick with a cold. During the brief call, Jean reiterated her false alibi, telling Sophie that she “had to work for eight hours” and would probably not be coming home that night. This call is the last confirmed verbal communication from Spangler, and her deliberate lie about her plans remains a key element of the mystery.
13. A Mysterious Companion
In the midst of the police investigation, a park employee and a college student came forward to report a strange occurrence at the Griffith Park area around the time Spangler’s purse was found. They claimed to have seen a woman matching Spangler’s description and a man in the area a day or two earlier. The woman appeared to be injured or ill and was leaning against the man. The man’s face was obscured, but his suit was described as being “brown or tan.” This possible sighting, though unconfirmed, suggested that Spangler might have been in distress and in the company of a mysterious male companion.
14. Theories of Fleeing the City
Despite the grim clues of a struggle and foul play, another prominent theory suggested that Jean Spangler may have willfully fled Los Angeles to escape a complicated personal life or to start fresh elsewhere. The note to “Kirk” and “Dr. Scott,” while ominous, could also be interpreted as Spangler’s way of informing someone she was leaving the area due to a difficult situation, such as the social stigma of an illegal pregnancy or her entanglement with organized crime. However, no evidence of her presence, or any new identity, was ever discovered anywhere in the United States.
The case of Jean Spangler is a tragic postcard from Hollywood’s golden age, a haunting reminder that behind the silver screen glamour, real-life mysteries often defy the tidy ending of a movie script. Her vanishing act, wrapped in a few cryptic words and a tattered purse, ensures that the search for the aspiring actress and the answers to her last, frantic message continue to echo in the canyons of Los Angeles history.
Like this story? Add your thoughts in the comments, thank you.
This story The Cursed Life of Jean Spangler: 14 Clues in Hollywood’s Most Famous Missing Person Case was first published on Daily FETCH
