What Cesar Got Wrong:
1. Missed the Mark
Cesar’s obsession with being a “pack leader” falls flat. Dogs don’t misbehave because they’re trying to dominate you; often, they’re just scared, bored, or confused. This old-school approach ignores the reality of modern science: dogs thrive on trust, not fear. Forcing submission creates anxiety instead of good behavior. Training isn’t about proving who’s boss—it’s about teamwork. Maybe it’s time we give the “alpha” theory a rest and focus on building real bonds instead.
2. Harsh Dominance
Leash jerks, pokes, and “corrective” touches might seem like quick fixes, but they often backfire. Sure, they might stop bad behavior at the moment, but they can create long-term fear and aggression. No one likes being bullied, not even dogs. Today’s trainers swear by positive reinforcement—treats, praise, and patience. It’s kinder, smarter, and, let’s be real, way more effective. Cesar, let’s leave the rough stuff in the past, shall we?
3. Ignoring Fear
Picture this: your dog is terrified of the vacuum, and instead of helping them feel safe, you shove the machine in their face. Sound productive? Spoiler: it’s not. Cesar’s “facing fears” approach can traumatize dogs instead of helping them. Fear isn’t a challenge to overcome; it’s an emotion to be understood. Desensitization treats and encouragement work far better than brute force. Let’s help our pups feel safe, not scared.
4. Alpha Obsession
“Be the alpha!” Cesar preaches. But here’s the plot twist: the “alpha wolf” idea is outdated. Wolves in the wild aren’t obsessed with dominance, and dogs aren’t. Instead, they crave security and companionship, not power struggles. Training based on trust and mutual respect is scientifically proven to work better. Time to ditch the dominant mindset and embrace teamwork. Who’s a good boy? (Hint: It’s both of you!)
5. Misreading Cues
Your dog is cowering, tail tucked, and ears flat—but Cesar might call this “defiance.” Oops. Misinterpreting canine body language leads to the wrong responses, like punishing a scared dog when they need comfort. Dogs aren’t sneaky little rebels; they’re trying to communicate the best way they can. Learning the difference between fear, anxiety, and stubbornness is key to being a good trainer—or just a good dog parent.
6. Outdated Ideas
Here’s the tea: the “pack mentality” Cesar loves comes from flawed science. Researchers studied wolves in captivity and assumed their behaviors applied to dogs. Spoiler: they don’t. Dogs are domesticated animals, not wild predators plotting to overthrow you. Using this outdated theory can confuse owners and harm dogs. Let’s stick to modern, research-backed methods instead of clinging to myths.
7. Overusing Force
Cesar’s love of physical control—like holding dogs down—is a recipe for disaster. While it might “work” in extreme cases, it’s a fast track to breaking trust. Plus, it often makes aggressive behavior worse. Dogs respond best to consistent, clear communication—not force. Training shouldn’t feel like a wrestling match; it should feel like a partnership. Let’s leave the wrestling to the WWE.
What Cesar Got Right:
1. Calm Energy
Cesar nailed one thing: your vibe affects your dog. Dogs are emotional mirrors, and if you’re a stressed-out mess, they will be too. Staying calm, confident, and collected helps your dog feel safe and balanced. Whether you’re dealing with a barking frenzy or leash-pulling chaos, remember: chill out. Your dog will follow your lead. The real secret? It’s less about being a “pack leader” and more about being a zen master.
2. Exercise First
A tired dog is a good dog—simple as that. Cesar’s advice to prioritize exercise hits the nail on the head. Long walks, playtime, and mental stimulation work wonders for preventing bad behavior. Think of it like this: your dog isn’t chewing your shoes out of spite; they’re just bored. Burn off that energy, and you’ll have a much calmer, happier pup. Plus, it’s a great excuse to skip the gym. Win-win!
3. Clear Boundaries
Cesar gets it right when he talks about setting boundaries. Letting your dog run the show leads to chaos—no one wants a couch-hogging, counter-surfing tyrant. Clear rules, like no jumping on furniture or begging at the table, help your dog understand what’s expected. Dogs thrive on structure, and let’s face it, so do humans. It’s not about being bossy; it’s about creating harmony.
4. Pack Mentality
YouTube
While Cesar’s alpha theory misses the mark, he’s not wrong about teamwork. Dogs see their humans as part of their pack, and consistency among family members is crucial. If one person lets the dog beg at the table and another doesn’t, confusion reigns. Everyone in the “pack” needs to be on the same page. Teamwork makes the dream work, even for Fido.
5. Consistency Wins
Dogs are creatures of habit, and Cesar’s emphasis on consistency is spot-on. Training only works if everyone sticks to the rules. Use the same commands, reward good behavior, and stay patient. Whether teaching “sit” or dealing with barking fits, repetition is your best friend. Consistency builds trust, and trust is the foundation of a happy, well-behaved pup.
Cesar Millan has sparked plenty of debate in the dog-training world, and it’s easy to see why. While some of his methods are outdated, his emphasis on calm energy, exercise, and consistency remains timeless. By taking the good and leaving behind the outdated, dog owners can create a training approach that’s effective, humane, and rooted in modern science. Your dog isn’t just a pet—they’re family. Train them with love, and you’ll both be better for it.
