1. Planters Cheez Balls
Some snacks disappear from store shelves, but their memories stay surprisingly fresh. Planters Cheez Balls were a bright orange, crunchy snack sold in the iconic blue canister that many people still remember from childhood. First introduced in the 1980s, they became popular thanks to their bold cheesy flavor and melt-in-your-mouth texture. Although Planters discontinued them in 2006, long-running fan petitions and online nostalgia kept their memory alive. The snack briefly returned in limited releases beginning in 2018, selling out quickly each time. Many fans still discuss how the original version had a slightly different taste compared to the re-released batches, and the blue tin itself remains a recognizable collectible for snack lovers.
2. Dunkaroos
Dunkaroos launched in 1990 as a fun snack pack filled with mini cookies and a separate frosting compartment. Kids loved the mix-and-dip idea, and the kangaroo mascot made it even more memorable. The snack disappeared from most markets around 2012, which fueled a wave of nostalgia among millennials who grew up with it in school lunchboxes. Although Dunkaroos officially returned to U.S. shelves in 2020, the original 1990s versions remain a major part of the conversation because fans claim the earlier frosting flavors, especially chocolate and vanilla rainbow, had a unique sweetness that defined childhood snacking. Even with modern re-releases, many still talk about the excitement of peeling back the package lid for the first dip.
3. Butterfinger BB’s
Butterfinger BB’s were bite-sized chocolate-coated spheres introduced in 1992 and marketed heavily during the Bart Simpson advertising era. Fans loved that they delivered the classic Butterfinger flavor but in a poppable form that felt fun and easy to share. Despite their popularity, the candy was discontinued in 2006, reportedly due to issues with the coating melting too easily. People still reminisce about the BB’s unique texture and the way the candy rattled inside its small bag. Social media threads and nostalgia forums often discuss why the product has never returned, especially since many consider it one of the most missed candies of the 1990s.
4. Kudos Granola Bars
Kudos Granola Bars were introduced in the 1980s and became popular through the 1990s as a dessert-like granola bar coated or drizzled in chocolate. Many remember flavors like M&M’s, Snickers, and chocolate chip that made the bars feel more like a treat than a health snack. Over time, changes in consumer habits and evolving nutritional standards made the product less competitive, and it was eventually discontinued in the mid-2010s. People still talk about Kudos because it blended two worlds, snack bar and candy bar, in a way few products have matched since. The nostalgic packaging and the candy-inspired versions remain especially memorable.
5. Oreo Cakesters
Oreo Cakesters debuted in 2007 as a soft, cake-like version of the classic Oreo cookie. With their fluffy chocolate layers and creamy center, they quickly became popular among people wanting a twist on the traditional cookie. Despite gaining a strong fan base, the product was discontinued around 2012, leading to years of online requests for its return. Images of the original packaging and reviews from the late 2000s still circulate today because many remember Cakesters as a unique texture experience that tasted like a cross between an Oreo and a snack cake. Nabisco eventually revived them in 2022, but older fans continue to discuss how the first release felt especially nostalgic.
6. Jell-O Pudding Pops
Jell-O Pudding Pops first appeared in the late 1970s and became one of the most beloved freezer treats of the 1980s. Unlike traditional ice pops, these were creamy, pudding-based bars that came in chocolate, vanilla, and swirl flavors. Their smooth texture and rich taste made them a standout in grocery freezer aisles. Even after strong sales, the product was eventually discontinued by the early 2000s due to manufacturing and distribution issues. Fans still talk about how no modern remake quite captures the original’s texture, even though similar products have appeared over the years. For many, Pudding Pops remain a symbol of childhood summers and TV commercial nostalgia.
7. 3D Doritos
3D Doritos launched in 1998 as a puffed, tube-shaped version of the classic chip, and they quickly became a top snack of the late 1990s and early 2000s. Fans loved the airy crunch and the way the flavors, especially Nacho Cheese and Cool Ranch, felt lighter but still bold. The snack quietly disappeared in the 2000s, sparking years of online discussion among people who wished for its return. Doritos eventually revived a new version in 2020, but many say the original had a distinct texture that today’s version doesn’t fully replicate. That lingering debate keeps the discontinued classic alive in snack conversations everywhere.
8. PB Crisps
PB Crisps were introduced by Planters in the early 1990s and are still considered one of the most missed discontinued snacks. They featured a peanut-shaped cookie shell filled with a smooth peanut butter center, later branching into chocolate and other flavors. The combination of crunch and creamy filling made them especially memorable. Despite a loyal fan base, PB Crisps were pulled from shelves by the late ’90s, reportedly due to production costs and shifting brand priorities. Over the years, repeated petitions and social media campaigns have tried to bring them back, highlighting how deeply the snack resonated with people who grew up with it. Many still describe PB Crisps as their “ultimate lost snack.”
9. Trix Yogurt
Trix Yogurt, produced by Yoplait, became a lunchtime favorite in the late 1990s and 2000s thanks to its bright, swirled colors and kid-friendly sweetness. Unlike regular yogurt, it offered bold fruity flavors and visually fun combinations like pink and purple or blue and green. While it developed a strong following, the yogurt was discontinued in 2016 as companies shifted focus toward healthier, less sugary options. A revival came in 2020, but fans still talk about how the original versions felt more whimsical and flavorful. Its disappearance marked the end of an era in many school cafeterias, making it one of the most nostalgic discontinued snacks.
10. Rice Krispies Treats Cereal
Rice Krispies Treats Cereal was introduced in 1993 and became popular for transforming the classic marshmallow squares into a breakfast option. The cereal featured clusters of crispy rice lightly coated in a sweet marshmallow flavor that reminded many of homemade treats. Although widely enjoyed, it was discontinued in 2019 for reasons Kellogg’s never fully detailed, sparking disappointment among longtime fans. People still reminisce about how the cereal stayed crunchy while delivering a dessert-like taste, something few cereals have managed since. Its bright blue box and nostalgic commercials remain part of why fans continue to talk about this discontinued favorite.
11. Creme Savers
Creme Savers debuted in 1998 as a creamier, dessert-inspired twist on the classic Life Savers hard candy. Flavors like Strawberries and Cream and Orange and Cream quickly became favorites thanks to their smooth, layered taste that resembled fruit blended with whipped cream. Despite strong popularity in the early 2000s, the candy disappeared from store shelves around 2011 for reasons the brand never publicly explained. Fans spent years discussing its absence online, leading to petitions and nostalgic posts. Although a limited revival arrived in 2021 through select retailers, many still talk fondly about the original versions, their swirl design, and the signature creamy flavor that newer candy products rarely match.
12. Squeezit
Squeezit, introduced in 1985, was a fruit-flavored kids’ drink sold in bright, squeezable plastic bottles shaped like cartoon characters. Each flavor had its own personality, and some versions even allowed kids to mix colors by adding a dissolvable “magic” color tablet. The drink became a staple in lunchboxes during the 1990s, but by 2001 it was discontinued in the United States due to declining demand. Even so, people still remember the fun of twisting off the cap and squeezing the bottle until it crinkled. For many, Squeezit stands out not just for its taste, but for its playful packaging that made it feel more like a toy than a drink.
13. Altoids Sours
Altoids Sours were launched in 2004 as a tangy spin on the brand’s traditional mints, offering flavors like Tangerine, Raspberry, and Citrus. Packaged in small metal tins similar to classic Altoids, the candies gained a cult following because of their intense sour punch and dusted texture. Despite strong fan enthusiasm, the product was discontinued in 2010 due to what the company described as limited demand. In the years since, they’ve become a highly nostalgic item, and empty tins often appear on resale sites. Many people still swap memories about how quickly the candies dissolved and how addictive the sour flavor felt, keeping them alive in online nostalgia discussions.
14. Pepsi Blue
Pepsi Blue arrived in 2002 with a vibrant electric-blue color and a berry-flavored twist aimed at younger consumers. Despite a massive marketing push, including celebrity endorsements, the drink lasted only about two years in North America before being discontinued in 2004. Fans, however, never stopped talking about it. Its unusual color, candy-like sweetness, and early-2000s branding helped cement its status as a nostalgic favorite. Pepsi briefly re-released Pepsi Blue in 2021 for a limited run, which quickly sold out in many places and reignited discussion about how the drink captured a specific moment in pop culture. Many still recall it as one of the boldest sodas of its time.
15. French Toast Crunch (Original Version)
French Toast Crunch debuted in 1995 and became beloved for its tiny, toast-shaped cereal pieces coated in a sweet maple flavor. While it enjoyed early success, the cereal was discontinued in the United States in 2006 as General Mills streamlined its product lineup. Fans continued discussing it for years, comparing its unique shape and taste to other breakfast cereals that never quite matched its nostalgic appeal. After widespread demand, the cereal returned in 2014, though some longtime fans insist the original 1990s formula had a slightly richer maple flavor. Regardless of version, French Toast Crunch remains one of the most talked-about discontinued cereals of its era.
16. Fruit String Thing
Fruit String Thing, introduced by Betty Crocker in the 1990s, was a fruit-flavored snack known for its long, peelable string designs that often came shaped into spirals or patterns. Kids enjoyed unrolling it piece by piece, making it feel more interactive than other fruit snacks of the time. While it tasted similar to other fruity treats, its playful presentation helped it stand out in lunchboxes throughout the decade. The snack gradually disappeared in the early 2000s as the company shifted its focus to other fruit snack brands. Fans still reminisce about the distinctive red packaging and the way the snack stuck lightly to itself when peeled apart, something many say has never been recreated quite the same way.
17. Wonder Ball (Original Version)
The original Wonder Ball, released by Nestlé in the mid-1990s, featured a hollow chocolate sphere with a small toy inside, making it an exciting surprise candy for kids. Its concept echoed the famous Kinder Surprise, though U.S. regulations on embedded toys eventually led to concerns about safety. By 1997, the product was discontinued due to these issues. It later returned in the early 2000s with candy pieces inside instead of toys, but many fans still talk specifically about the original version because of the thrill of cracking open the chocolate to reveal the hidden figurine. The toy-in-chocolate formula remains a nostalgic symbol of ’90s novelty candy culture.
18. Shark Bites
Shark Bites fruit snacks became a big hit in the 1990s, thanks to their colorful sea-themed shapes and the rare, coveted “white shark” piece that many kids hoped to find in each pouch. Produced by Betty Crocker, the snacks had firmer textures and more distinct flavors than many fruit snacks of the time, which helped them stand out on store shelves. As product lines evolved, the original Shark Bites were phased out in the 2000s. Fans still reminisce about comparing shark shapes at lunchtime and the excitement around spotting the white shark, which became a playful status symbol in school cafeterias. Their unique mix of flavor and theme keeps them frequently discussed today.
19. Ouch! Bubble Gum
Ouch! Bubble Gum, sold in colorful tins resembling miniature first-aid kits, became popular in the 1990s for its playful design as much as its sweet, soft gum strips. Each piece looked like a candy version of a bandage, and flavors typically included grape, watermelon, and strawberry. The novelty packaging made it a favorite among kids who often kept the tins long after the gum was gone. Despite its popularity, the gum eventually disappeared from shelves in the early 2000s as novelty candies shifted toward trendier formats. Even today, people still recall the excitement of sliding open the metal tin and choosing a “bandage” stick of gum to share with friends.
20. Swoops
Hershey’s Swoops, introduced in 2003, were thin, curved chocolate pieces shaped like potato chips and designed to deliver a melt-in-your-mouth experience. They came in several varieties, including Reese’s, Almond Joy, and York, making them appealing to fans of existing candy brands. Despite positive reactions to the flavor, Swoops struggled to maintain strong sales and were discontinued by 2006. People still talk about the candy because its shape was so unusual, and the idea of chocolate molded into crisp, chip-like slices remains relatively rare. Nostalgia discussions often highlight how satisfying it was to let a Swoops piece dissolve slowly rather than bite into it.
21. Crystal Pepsi
Crystal Pepsi debuted in 1992 as part of the early-’90s clear-product craze, offering a caffeine-free cola with a transparent look that set it apart from traditional sodas. Although heavily marketed, including major Super Bowl ads, its lighter flavor and unconventional appearance divided consumers. The drink was discontinued in North America by 1994 but remained a strong nostalgic symbol thanks to its distinctive aesthetic and short-lived novelty. Limited-time re-releases in the 2010s reignited conversation, though many fans still insist the original formula had a cleaner, crisper taste. Its unique place in pop culture ensures that Crystal Pepsi remains one of the most talked-about discontinued beverages of the decade.
22. Keebler Magic Middles
Keebler Magic Middles were soft, shortbread-like cookies filled with a creamy fudge or peanut butter center. Released in the 1980s and popular into the early 1990s, they stood out because the filling stayed soft even after baking, creating a warm, melty surprise when bitten into. Despite a loyal following, the cookies were discontinued by the mid-1990s as Keebler narrowed its product line. Over the years, social media threads and petitions have frequently called for their return, with fans describing them as one of the most satisfying cookies ever made. Their blend of soft cookie exterior and rich center keeps them alive in snack nostalgia conversations.
23. Hubba Bubba Bubble Jug
Hubba Bubba’s Bubble Jug was a 1990s favorite known for its unique powdered gum: a sweet, grainy candy powder that turned into chewy gum as soon as it hit your tongue. The product came in a bright plastic jug, making it fun for kids to shake and pour. Flavors like Tropical and Watermelon helped it become a lunchbox novelty. Although widely remembered, Bubble Jug eventually disappeared from shelves in the 2000s as gum brands moved toward more conventional formats. Fans still talk about how unusual the transformation from powder to gum felt and how the sugary dust always seemed to leave a colorful residue on fingertips.
24. Clearly Canadian (Original Formulation)
Clearly Canadian became a cultural staple in the 1990s thanks to its sleek teardrop-shaped glass bottles and lightly sweetened sparkling flavors like Wild Cherry, Orchard Peach, and Mountain Blackberry. The drink gained a strong following, appearing in TV shows and school vending machines. By the late 2000s, the original formulation largely disappeared due to production and distribution challenges. Although the brand returned in the 2010s, many fans still reminisce about the original taste and bottle design, which they say had a crisper, more refreshing profile. Its nostalgia-driven revival shows how powerful memories of discontinued drinks can be.
25. Rold Gold Honey Mustard Tiny Twists
Rold Gold’s Honey Mustard Tiny Twists were a popular pretzel flavor in the 1990s and early 2000s, standing out for their strong sweet-and-tangy seasoning. Many snack fans remember them as a staple in lunchboxes and road trip snack bags. Despite their popularity, the flavor was discontinued as Rold Gold shifted to a smaller core lineup, leaving many people searching store shelves in vain. Over time, the pretzels developed a cult following, with consumers comparing them to newer honey mustard snacks that never quite matched the original’s sharp flavor. Their disappearance remains a frequent topic in nostalgic snack forums.
26. S’mores Pop-Tarts (Original Recipe)
S’mores Pop-Tarts first appeared in the 1990s and quickly became a favorite because of their combination of chocolate, graham, and marshmallow flavors. While the flavor still exists today, fans of the original recipe say the earliest version had a richer marshmallow filling and a slightly different frosting pattern. Kellogg’s updated the formula over the years, which led many people to treat the original as a “lost” version of the snack. Nostalgia discussions still highlight how the early S’mores Pop-Tarts tasted closer to an actual campfire treat, and photos of the 1990s packaging often appear in online threads dedicated to discontinued or altered snack recipes.
27. Yogos
Yogos were yogurt-covered fruit snack bites introduced by Kellogg’s in the mid-2000s. Their colorful, glossy coating and chewy centers made them feel different from typical fruit snacks, and flavors like Berry-Berry and Crazy Berries became quick favorites among children. Despite a strong following, Yogos were discontinued around 2010, reportedly due to production challenges and shifting brand priorities. Fans often reminisce about the uniquely tangy coating and the small pouches perfect for school lunches. Today, Yogos remain one of the most requested discontinued snacks in fan petitions, with many people still hoping for a future revival.
28. Pizza Spins
Pizza Spins, produced by General Mills in the 1970s, offered a pizza-flavored corn snack shaped like small wheels. Their bold seasoning, featuring cheese, tomato, and herbs, made them stand out at a time when pizza-flavored snacks were relatively new to the market. Despite strong early interest, Pizza Spins were discontinued by the late 1970s, making them a rarity even among nostalgic snack lists. People who grew up with the snack still recall its zesty flavor and unusual wheel shape, and vintage photos of the packaging circulate online among retro-food enthusiasts. Their short run only adds to the fascination and discussions surrounding their disappearance.
29. Pizzarias Pizza Chips
Keebler’s Pizzarias Pizza Chips, introduced in 1991, were made from real pizza dough, giving them a uniquely crisp texture and stronger pizza flavor than typical potato chips. Flavors included Cheese Pizza, Supreme, and Pizza Cravers, and many people remember the lively commercials featuring the Keebler Elves. Despite strong popularity, Pizzarias were discontinued by the late 1990s when Keebler shifted focus to other product lines. The chips remain a major topic in snack nostalgia groups, where fans often describe them as one of the most accurate pizza-flavored snacks ever sold. Their blend of crunch and robust seasoning has never been fully replicated.
30. Four Loko (Original Formula)
The original formula of Four Loko, released in 2008, was a caffeinated alcoholic beverage combining malt liquor with energy-drink-style stimulants. It gained widespread attention, both positive and controversial, because of its sweet flavors and high alcohol content paired with caffeine. After growing safety concerns, the FDA pressured manufacturers in 2010 to remove caffeine, taurine, and guarana from the drink. The reformulated version remains available today, but the original formula is often discussed as a notorious “discontinued” product due to its impact on college culture and the national debate it sparked. Its bright cans and intense reputation keep it alive in online memory even years after the formula changed.
Whether it was the taste, the packaging, or simply the moment in life when we enjoyed them most, these treats continue to spark conversations and nostalgia. As trends shift and new products come and go, these forgotten favorites remind us how powerful a simple snack can be in capturing the spirit of a time.
This was first published on Daily FETCH on Dec 8th, 2025
