1. Orijen – The Gold Standard of Dog Food
When it comes to high-quality dog food, Orijen consistently ranks at the top. This brand prides itself on using biologically appropriate ingredients, meaning it closely mimics what dogs would eat in the wild. Their recipes are packed with fresh, regional meats like free-run chicken, wild-caught fish, and ranch-raised beef. Plus, they skip the fillers, artificial preservatives, and questionable byproducts that many cheaper brands sneak into their formulas.
Orijen is not just high in protein but also rich in essential vitamins and minerals that support overall canine health. Dogs fed this brand often have shinier coats, better digestion, and improved energy levels. However, this level of quality comes with a price tag, and Orijen is one of the most expensive dog food brands out there. But for pet owners who want the absolute best and are willing to invest in their dog’s long-term health, Orijen is worth every penny.
2. Blue Buffalo – A Mixed Bag
Blue Buffalo has built a strong reputation with its “Life Protection Formula,” boasting natural ingredients and no artificial additives. At first glance, it seems like an excellent choice for health-conscious dog owners. Many pet parents have seen positive results, such as better digestion, increased energy, and reduced allergies in their furry friends. However, Blue Buffalo has had its fair share of controversy, including multiple recalls and lawsuits over misleading ingredient claims.
The brand has been criticized for inconsistency in its formulas, which has led to digestive issues in some dogs. While many Blue Buffalo products are high in quality, some of their lower-tier formulas contain more grains and less premium protein sources. If you’re considering this brand, it’s essential to scrutinize the ingredient list carefully. It can be a great option, but not every bag of Blue Buffalo is created equal.
3. Taste of the Wild – A Budget-Friendly Premium Option
If you want high-quality dog food without completely draining your wallet, Taste of the Wild is a solid choice. This brand focuses on grain-free recipes inspired by what wild dogs would eat, incorporating novel proteins like bison, venison, and trout. It also includes probiotics for gut health, which is a huge plus for dogs with sensitive stomachs. Many pet owners report shinier coats and fewer allergies after switching to this brand.
However, while Taste of the Wild is a step above many supermarket brands, it’s not quite at the level of Orijen or Acana in terms of ingredient sourcing. Some recipes contain more plant-based proteins than animal-based ones, which can be misleading when looking at the protein percentage. Still, for those seeking a middle-ground option between premium and affordable, this brand offers great value. It’s not the absolute best, but it’s certainly not the worst.
4. Pedigree – The Fast Food of Dog Food
Pedigree is one of the most well-known dog food brands, and you can find it in just about any grocery store. It’s cheap, convenient, and heavily marketed as a healthy choice for dogs. But when you take a closer look at the ingredients, the reality is disappointing. The first ingredient in many Pedigree formulas is corn or some form of grain filler rather than real meat. These fillers provide little nutritional value and can contribute to weight gain and digestive issues.
While some dogs do just fine on Pedigree, many pet owners report dull coats, excessive shedding, and allergies developing over time. The brand also uses artificial colors and preservatives, which aren’t necessary in a dog’s diet. Sure, it’s affordable, but the long-term health costs might outweigh the short-term savings. If you can, it’s worth spending a little more for a higher-quality brand that prioritizes real, whole-food ingredients.
5. Merrick – Quality Ingredients, But Not Without Flaws
Merrick is another brand that positions itself as high-quality, and for the most part, it delivers. The company uses locally sourced, fresh ingredients and offers a variety of grain-free and limited-ingredient diets. Their recipes are packed with real meats, sweet potatoes, and fresh fruits and vegetables, making them a favorite among picky eaters. Dogs on Merrick often have great muscle tone and high energy levels, which speaks to the quality of the ingredients.
However, some dog owners have reported digestive issues and inconsistent quality between batches. Merrick was also acquired by Purina a few years ago, which raised concerns about potential ingredient changes. While the brand still maintains a relatively strong reputation, some long-time customers feel the quality has slightly declined. It’s a decent option, but if you’re ultra-picky about your dog’s food, you might want to keep an eye on any formulation changes.
6. Beneful – A Brand to Avoid
Beneful might look appealing with its bright packaging and pictures of fresh ingredients, but don’t be fooled. This brand has been under fire for using artificial dyes, high levels of grain fillers, and questionable meat byproducts. In fact, some pet owners have reported serious health issues in their dogs after long-term consumption of Beneful. From digestive problems to skin conditions, the list of complaints is long.
One of the biggest red flags is the use of propylene glycol, a controversial ingredient also found in antifreeze (though in a different form). While Beneful meets the minimum nutritional requirements, it does so in a way that prioritizes cost-cutting over real nutrition. It’s one of those brands that may keep your dog fed but not necessarily thriving. If you love your pup, this is one to leave on the shelf.
Click here for more stories like this
7. Acana – High-Quality and Nutrient-Dense
Acana is made by the same company as Orijen, but it comes at a slightly lower price point while still maintaining impressive quality. Their formulas include fresh, regionally sourced ingredients like free-run poultry, wild-caught fish, and ranch-raised beef. Acana also avoids fillers like corn, wheat, and soy, making it a great option for dogs with food sensitivities. The company emphasizes a biologically appropriate diet, which means more meat and fewer unnecessary carbs.
Many pet owners see significant health improvements after switching to Acana, including better digestion, shinier coats, and higher energy levels. However, the lower cost compared to Orijen does mean slightly less protein variety in some formulas. That said, it’s still a far superior choice compared to most grocery store brands. If you want premium dog food but don’t want to splurge on Orijen, Acana is an excellent alternative.
8. Purina Pro Plan – Surprisingly Solid
Purina has a mixed reputation, but their Pro Plan line is actually a decent choice. Unlike Purina’s cheaper offerings, Pro Plan focuses on higher-quality proteins and includes live probiotics for digestive health. Many veterinarians recommend this brand, especially for active and working dogs who need strong muscle support. While it does contain grains, they are usually whole grains rather than cheap fillers like corn or wheat gluten.
However, Pro Plan isn’t without its drawbacks. Some formulas still contain meat byproducts and artificial additives, which isn’t ideal. While it’s better than basic Purina or other budget brands, it’s not quite at the level of Orijen, Acana, or even Taste of the Wild. If you’re looking for a balance between affordability and quality, though, it’s one of the better options in the mid-tier range.
9. Hill’s Science Diet – Vet-Recommended but Controversial
Hill’s Science Diet is one of the most frequently recommended brands by veterinarians. It has a long-standing reputation for being scientifically formulated to meet dogs’ nutritional needs. Many of their specialty diets, such as those for weight management or kidney support, have been life-changing for dogs with medical conditions. The brand also puts a strong emphasis on quality control and rigorous testing.
However, Hill’s Science Diet isn’t perfect. Many of their formulas rely heavily on grains and meat byproducts rather than whole, high-quality meats. This makes it a less desirable choice for pet owners looking for an all-natural, high-protein diet. While it’s not the worst brand out there, it’s also not the most premium, and the ingredients may not justify the high price for some owners.
10. Iams – A Step Above the Worst
Iams is another widely available brand that has been around for decades. It’s better than some bottom-tier brands like Pedigree and Beneful, but it still contains a lot of grain fillers. The protein sources are not always the best, often relying on meat byproducts rather than whole meats. While it meets basic nutritional requirements, it doesn’t necessarily offer the best long-term health benefits.
That said, some dogs do fine on Iams, and it is at least free from artificial dyes and propylene glycol, which some cheaper brands still use. If budget is a major concern, Iams is a better choice than the absolute worst brands, but it’s not the best option for optimal nutrition. If you can afford to go a step higher, your dog will likely benefit from a more premium food.
11. Wellness Core – A Solid High-Protein Option
Wellness Core is another brand that’s highly regarded for its grain-free, high-protein formulas. It focuses on using real meat, wholesome fruits and vegetables, and beneficial probiotics. Many pet owners report healthier skin, reduced allergies, and more energy after switching their dogs to Wellness Core. Their recipes also avoid artificial preservatives and cheap fillers, making them one of the better options on the market.
However, some dogs experience digestive issues with Wellness Core, possibly due to the high protein content. It’s great for active dogs, but for more sedentary pups, the richness of the formula might be too much. Still, it’s a high-quality brand that generally delivers on its promises. If you’re looking for a nutrient-dense option, Wellness Core is definitely worth considering.
12. Kibbles ‘n Bits – A Hard Pass
Kibbles ‘n Bits is one of the worst offenders when it comes to cheap, low-quality dog food. It’s packed with artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives, none of which are necessary for a dog’s diet. The first ingredients are often corn and soybean meal, with actual meat appearing much lower on the list. Many pet owners report digestive issues, dull coats, and even allergic reactions in dogs that eat this brand regularly.
The bright-colored kibble may look fun, but it’s a major red flag when it comes to nutrition. Artificial dyes have been linked to health concerns in both humans and animals, making them completely unnecessary in dog food. While Kibbles ‘n Bits is budget-friendly, it comes at a long-term cost to your dog’s health. If you love your pet, it’s best to leave this brand on the shelf.
